Published: November 16, 2026
Nine Democratic senators told Commodity Futures Trading Commission Chair Michael Selig to walk back his November 5 interpretation ordering designated contract markets to drop state-by-state geofencing. Senator Adam Schiff of California is leading the push, arguing the guidance runs straight into active court orders in California, Michigan, Nevada, and Washington and undercuts state and tribal gaming laws. The Senate group says the move is pushing platforms to ignore judges while the cases are still live.
In the letter sent Monday, they want the interpretation withdrawn outright or frozen until the litigation finishes. They also want the agency to state clearly that court-ordered limits, Indian Gaming Regulatory Act restrictions, and any voluntary steps exchanges take do not violate Regulation 38.151(b). On top of that, they are demanding a full records hold covering everything from January 1, 2025, forward and written confirmation by November 23.
Schiff posted about it on X, saying the CFTC is trying to force contracts into all 50 states and onto tribal lands, violating state and federal law, court orders, and tribal sovereignty. He called the whole thing lawless. (Of course, Congress could pass a law covering this issue.)
What The November 5 Interpretation Requires
The guidance came out as Release No. 9323-26 and interprets the impartial access rules in Commission Regulation 38.151(b). Those rules call for competitive, open, fair, and impartial access for members and traders. Chairman Selig said derivatives markets must operate on a uniform national basis to fulfill the purposes of the Commodity Exchange Act, and that geographic restrictions get in the way.
Designated contract markets now have 30 days to end any domestic geographic limits that break the rule or explain to the Division of Market Oversight why they cannot. They also have to make sure intermediaries are not blocking the same access or file their own explanation. The agency says it will review the facts of each case before doing anything else. The full release is on the CFTC site.
The interpretation landed hours after a Northern District of California order in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi that requires geofencing around the lands of Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians. Senators called the timing troubling and suggested the agency might be coordinating with platforms already fighting the same issue in court.
Court Rulings And The Senators Request
Judges have already told platforms to restrict access in Michigan, Nevada, and Washington as well as on specific tribal lands in California. Several courts have treated sports-related event contracts as sports wagers under state and tribal gaming laws instead of swaps. The Sixth and Ninth Circuits have both said states keep the power to apply their own gaming statutes and that certain contracts entered on tribal land amount to unauthorized Class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.
In the Blue Lake Rancheria case, the Ninth Circuit found the tribes were likely to succeed, and the district court followed with a preliminary injunction. Senators argue the CFTC guidance is now pressuring platforms to offer contracts that judges have already barred. They want the agency to say outright that court-imposed geofencing does not break the impartial access requirement.
The Democratic Senator signers are Schiff, Catherine Cortez Masto, and Jacky Rosen of Nevada; Maria Cantwell and Patty Murray of Washington; Elissa Slotkin and Gary Peters of Michigan; Alex Padilla of California; and Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, the ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee. The full letter is posted on Senator Schiff’s site.
Selig’s Stance On National Markets And Jurisdiction
Selig keeps returning to the idea that markets need to operate the same way everywhere. In the November 5 release, he said geographic barriers undermine the uniform national trading the Commodity Exchange Act is built for. He has also said in other remarks that the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction and that states should not treat these contracts as unlicensed gambling.
He has signaled the agency will take the fight to the Supreme Court if it has to. An Axios interview where he walks through the jurisdiction question is on YouTube here.
During his confirmation hearing, Schiff pressed him on whether sports-related contracts count as gaming. A clip of that exchange is still up on YouTube here. Senators now say the November 5 interpretation goes further than anything Selig said earlier and has no real precedent under the impartial access rule for forcing nationwide access against existing court orders.
Immediate Requests And Remaining Conflicts
The letter asks for a reply by November 23 that confirms the records are being held. It also tells the commission to stop steering platforms toward contracts judges have already prohibited. By asking for clear exceptions covering court orders, Indian Gaming Regulatory Act rules, and voluntary limits, the senators are trying to stop the interpretation from running over active cases.
Circuit courts have sided with states and tribes on how these contracts should be classified while the CFTC, under Selig, keeps insisting national uniformity is required by statute. That leaves designated contract markets stuck between what the regulator says and what judges have ordered.
Democrats are expected to take the majority on the Senate Agriculture Committee that oversees the CFTC in the next couple of months, so this letter is also a warning shot. The senators want the agency to hold off on implementing the guidance until courts sort out the conflicts, rather than settling them through a unilateral interpretation.
References
- Senator Adam Schiff press release containing the letter to CFTC Chair Selig
- CFTC Release No. 9323-26 on the Impartial Access Requirements Interpretation
- Senator Adam Schiff post on X about the CFTC decision
- CDC Gaming report on the senators’ letter and records request
- CoinDesk coverage of the Democratic senators’ demand
- Axios interview with CFTC Chair Michael Selig on prediction markets and jurisdiction
- YouTube clip of Senator Schiff questioning CFTC nominee Michael Selig
