Published: November 17, 2026
The 60th CMA Awards are set for Wednesday night at Bridgestone Arena in Nashville, and the New Artist of the Year race already has traders locked in. Stephen Wilson Jr. sits near 58% on both Polymarket and Kalshi, ahead of Tucker Wetmore, as Lainey Wilson hosts for a third year and the show goes live on ABC and Disney+.
Wilson Jr. carries four nominations into the night, including Male Vocalist of the Year and the Song and Music Video slots for “Gary.” Wetmore arrives on the back of “Brunette,” the track that finally gave him a Country Airplay No. 1. Avery Anna, Carter Faith, and Emily Ann Roberts sit well back in the markets. Both Wilson Jr. and Wetmore watched Zach Top take the same trophy last year.
Stephen Wilson Jr. Dominates Prediction Markets
Traders have kept Stephen Wilson Jr. as the clear favorite in the final stretch. His contract holds around 58% on Kalshi and shows a similar reading on Polymarket, while Tucker Wetmore trails near 34% on both. Emily Ann Roberts sits closer to 8%. Kalshi volume has reached roughly $16,747 without any last-minute surge.

Wilson Jr.’s lead rests on the way “Gary” landed. He wrote the song alone after spotting a memorial billboard, then co-directed the video that puts Gary Sinise in the lead role. That mix of personal writing and wider ballot presence is what traders keep pricing in. Wetmore’s radio and streaming numbers still draw attention from people covering the category, yet the contracts have moved toward Wilson Jr. over the past few days.
Wetmore’s case stays simple and loud. “Brunette” caught fire after early TikTok clips and climbed to the top of Country Airplay, following a couple of earlier top-five hits. Contracts on Avery Anna and Carter Faith barely trade above a couple of points, so most of the action stays between the top two. A strong performance or a sudden clip could still nudge the numbers before the envelopes open.
How the Artists Stack Up for New Artist of the Year
Wilson Jr. has spent the year making the live room feel smaller. His CMA Fest take on “Gary” showed how the song sits when the lights drop, and he is set to share the stage with Chris Stapleton on the telecast. The official music video for “Gary” on YouTube captures the same grounded storytelling that earned the extra nomination.
Wetmore plays the opposite card. “Brunette” moves fast, runs short, and sticks in the head, the kind of track that fits radio rotation without much effort. He also has a performance slot on the show, which gives him one more direct shot at the room. The lyric video for the song on YouTube has already pulled millions of views, proof that the digital side of his campaign is working.
Wilson Jr.’s four nominations spread his name across more categories, while Wetmore’s single big hit keeps him in constant rotation. Writers covering the race have landed on different sides, with some pointing to Wetmore’s chart climb and others noting how Wilson Jr. has become a favorite among voters. The other three nominees bring their own styles, but the thinner trading on their contracts shows where the money has settled.

What Traders Are Watching Before the Show
With the show less than a day out, traders are watching for any fresh clips or posts from the nominees. Both Wilson Jr. and Wetmore have confirmed performance slots, so new footage could still move the conversation. The Bridgestone Arena setup and Lainey Wilson’s third year in the host chair give the night a clear milestone feel, complete with tributes and bigger names filling the card.
Polymarket and Kalshi will settle once the official CMA result is in. Prices have stayed steady near that 58% mark for Wilson Jr., with no sharp late swings so far. Other categories on the same platforms look more one-sided, especially where Ella Langley’s “Choosin’ Texas” run has set the tone. New Artist of the Year remains the tighter race even with Wilson Jr. in front. The live show airs on ABC and Disney+, then lands on Hulu the next day.
Wilson Jr. walks in with the market edge, but Wetmore’s chart run still leaves the door open once Nashville starts handing out the trophies.
References
- Kalshi CMA Awards New Artist of the Year Market
- Polymarket CMA New Artist of the Year 2026
- 60th Annual CMA Awards Wikipedia
- Billboard 2026 CMA Awards Predictions
- Stephen Wilson Jr. – Gary (Official Music Video)
- Tucker Wetmore – Brunette
- Big Loud on Stephen Wilson Jr. Nominations
- CMA First Round of Performers Announcement
- People Magazine CMA Nominations Coverage
- The Tennessean CMA Awards Overview
